You are in the company of Roger Warren Evans, Welsh socialist lawyer and company director, on a journey to work out a new socialist order capable of generating equality and freedom for the world.  Nothing less will do.
   

 my   What Hutton should say

Fight to the Death, broadcast on Wednesday evening was a riveting,
low-key TV programme, in the best BBC tradition.  The facts were set out,
with objectivity. 
And for me, a clear picture emerged.

My conclusion is that Dr Kelly died for reasons that were deeply personal
to the man himself, a man who was drawn fatally to the flame of public
recognition.  His public “naming” was not responsible for his death, indeed, I find no evidence that
he even resented it.  And the machinations of
Downing Street, awful as they were, were not the
cause of his death, although they undoubtedly triggered off the process during which he took
his own life.  Fight to the Death left no doubt that the probity of
Downing Street, the Joint
Intelligence Committee, and the independence of the Civil Service were
suborned by the Blair cabal.   It exposed the new-found, facile and inappropriate preoccupation of the BBC with “scoop journalism”, the delusions of
omnicompetence from which BBC managers clearly suffer, and the pusillanimity
of Gavyn Davies and the BBC Governors, who believed that the BBC could do no wrong.   It exposed the pitiful weakness of Geoff Hoon, reduced to a
mere cipher in the Downing Street subornation process.

But none of that explains David Kelly’s death.   My conclusion is that he died
at his own hand because, as a sensitive and honest man, he could not live with
himself.  Authorised by the MOD  to brief the media on technical weapons matters
(his telephone list extended to 26 different journalists), he went too far in his meeting
with scoop-specialist Andrew Gilligan.  It is clear that he initiated a damning criticism
of the
Downing Street process.  Gilligan, hungry for the kind of scoop that the BBC
expected from him, certainly went too far in its reporting.  His sloppy use of language
and sloppy ethical sense also caught him out.  But in the subsequent processes
Kelly found himself drawn – at his own instigation – into a web of half-truth in
which he became caught in untruths himself.  In his own mind, he perceived a
formal distinction between speaking “on the record” and “off the record” upon
which only a naïve man would have placed reliance. 

  • For the Ba’hai faith, to which he was a convert of five years’ standing, “the truth”
    is the central unifying concept.  Ba’hai dispenses with any more specific concepts
    of deity and seeks universality in a common allegiance to “the truth”.  Yet David Kelly,
    having at his own intitiative flown too near the flame of celebrity, had taken himself
    into a shadowy world of half-truth and innuendo. 

He could not live with that.


< Back to Home Page

 



New
Living Diary
Index


Renewing participatory democracy

My Little Red Book

A New Socialist Settlement

Bevan
Re-visited
 

Multiple Differential Uncertainty


Who am I? Biography  

     


0154  Make sure you have not missed
the previous edition 
Check it out   
And the one before that?   
Other recent topics highlighted here

Week 4  Sunday
25 January 2004


Blair did not lie

My critique of Blair's character suggests a faultline much deeper than "lying".  After all, honesty itself is a fragile construct, and we all have little ways of retaining our own belief in our own honesty and that of those near and dear to us. 

In the case of Blair, my unease goes much deeper.  It is that his character lies in a carapace, an empty shell which shields him from himself.  Within that carapace, he is always honest, motives are always genuine, promises are always kept, pledges genuinely given, the sun always shines. His problem is not a propensity to lie, but in an enormous capacity for profound self-delusion, self-persuasion.  He is the Walter Mitty.

I watched his performance on Paxman and the Students on Monday evening.  There can be no doubt that, in common sense terms, Labour has broken two manifesto pledges - (i) not to introduce top-up fees and (ii) not to increase Income Tax - when the scheme can now clearly seen as an Income Tax increase for students who have not been able to pay their way through university.  Yet he cannot admit that: within his carapace, all was sweetness and ordered light, which only the purblind could not see.

Now - for my part, I find "Manifesto politics" totally unsatisfactory, and I wish the Parties would not play that game: see Mandate Schmandate.  But "keeping manifesto promises" has been part of Blair's carapace from the start, and he is now trapped in its tortuous complexities.  Labour has benefited from his confidence, his eloquence, and his flair.  And he will formally "survive" his next High Noon.

  • But it is nevertheless time for him to go.  That carapace is wearing very, very thin.



Forget stable doors:
Radical new stable
designs needed

When will we ever learn?  Two years have passed since the beginning of the current wave of corporate fraud and deceit.  This week the first of the Enron “big fish” 42-year old Andrew Fastow pleaded guilty to just two of the 98 fraud charges brought against him in New York.  He will go to prison in May - but he will conveniently look after his children in the meantime, while his wife serves her agreed five-month term inside.  Since Enron, the evidence of corruption and deceit has continued to flow, currently with with Ahold, Adecco and Parmalat. 

Yet Governments have only tinkered with a rule here, a rule there, with the US Government being the most radical.  The truth is that we are using the wrong methods, to police the corporate sector. Our Clousots always arrive long after the damage has been done. Threatening to “punish” the fraudsters is pointless, because they can get away with £-billions before they are discovered – in Fastow’s case $45m, it is estimated.  The only solution is to re-design company law so that secrecy is reduced, to ensure greater generic publicity for company affairs, more effective media access, greater routine public scrutiny, more effective internal checks-and-balances. These guys must be watched. 

This will require intensive cooperation between Governments, and a deep commitment to justice.  A new international Company Reform Treaty is required.  And that is what we are targeting, in the Company Reform Coalition

back to top


Chilling Seasonal  Message

Tucked away in The Observer, just before Christmas, was a chilling insight into the mind of the Home Secretary David Blunkett.  It was his personal credo, backing his introduction in Parliament of yet another "tough" anti-immigration Bill.  I think he intended the piece to portray the image of a rational, perceptive, thinking politician. 

But it had the opposite effect.  His language is barren, his values bereft.  He is convinced that "the Left" has lost power elsewhere in Europe principally because of its failure to counter right-wing racism.

"Putting our heads in the sand is only an option if we and to go the way of the liberal Left in Europe".

He sees it as his destiny to become the bulwark against Fascist advance in Europe, by trumping their cards. He clearly has neither understanding nor sympathy for any "liberal" perspective, upon his anti-immigrant measures. 

back to top



No Laughing Matter

This is an appeal for your help. The collapse of public toilet provision in the UK is a serious matter.  Half of the nation's public loos have been closed down by local councils, within the last ten years. This scandal, and the consequential public health risks, are highlighted this week in The Guardian. 

Your help is needed.  I have registered a new public hygiene charity - Hygeia, Reg No 1,097,294 - check it out - which will be able to provide self-funding 24-hour public toilet facilities.  We are seeking the support of both private owners (shopping centres, malls) and local authorities.  And we need local eyes-and-ears throughout the UK, to identify the most urgent requirements.  We also need charity volunteers who take the issue seriously and are prepared to spend time and energy to help us solve the problem.

We do not need your money.  But we do need your intelligence, your concern, and your time.  If you know of local circumstances where provision needs to be made, or where local authority provision is threatened, we want to hear from you.

back to top


One year ago

Nothing quite matches, for me, the thrill of each New Year.  I am a sucker for the sense that dreams can still be achieved, old battles won, new causes undertaken.  It's more important, for me, than Christmas itself. For those of you with a moment to browse, this what I was thinking about - this time twelve months ago...

back to top


Surfing my Diary

For the first time in the two-year history of this Weblog, my diary was 100% up to date,  at Christmas!  'Twas a big effort, over the break, but you can now browse back over the entire 24-month period just click through 


 

..or rather - click here. 


Special Footnote

I love the online newspapers, which are my access to the world - share them with me - click through to their here -  I have added the English-language China Daily ... and I now offer you the leading English-language Indian paper The Hindu. 

They are all just a click away.

back to top


 

Never miss Steve Bell!  His cartoons, from The Guardian - his wit and perception illuminate the absurdities of the political scene...

back to top


 

     

Illogicality Matters...

In matter of political policy, I respect a strong sense of logic.  It is the sheer illogicality of the Scottish devolution formula that is perpetuating The West Lothian Question, in the run-up to the top-up fee vote.   And it is the bewildering illogicality of the Government's drugs policies has opened up a new Howard's way to attack the "downgrading" of cannabis. 


Martin Johnson's "retirement" will spur sales of these excellent Royal Mail celebration stamps.  I can imagine a new line in autographed postage stamps - who will be first to collect the whole team, with original signatures?  The prime set-of-four stamps is said to be sold out in the London area. 
  • Just pop down to South Wales - we've got plenty left!

Misguided St at e

I am dismayed by the awesome error now being made by the French Government, in its misguided ban on the wearing of Muslim headscarves in French schools.  I suspect it is the tragic outcome of personal rivalry, with Jacques Chirac trying to out-manoeuvre the rising Nicholas Sarkozy, and ruinously playing the xenophobic card.

I respect the secularism of the French state.  I value the principle that state institutions should not identify with any religion, or even with generic "religion".  Indeed, such secularism offers the best possible foundation for a successful modern multi-cultural society. 

But the wearing of the hijab to school by individual Muslim pupils is not an act of state.  It is an individual act, a personal choice, a discretion.  It constitutes precisely the exercise of personal freedom which the modern State should cherish and protect. 

  • How can the French
    get it so wrong?

What do you think?  


My letter to the Editor...

... of The Independent.  I am hopping mad with all the current proposals to strengthen the tax-collection functions of local authorities. Paradoxically, that is precisely the wrong way to go.  Local authorities should be relieved of the burden of collecting taxes, but given greater responsibility for deciding how tax income is best deployed for the benefit of their local communities.  That is the way to reinvigorate local government.

back to top


Awful straitjacket

The Green Belt penny may be about to drop.  I have long argued that its irrational constraints should be abandoned, and high-quality residential opportunities created.  Large country-park areas should be created, and residential development permitted within the framework of that park network. 

Government has now announced a new £63m budget, specifically for the creation of such country parks in South East England.  I welcome that, and encourage the Government to go much further with the creation of public country-parks.  I am fed up with planning authorities who continue to peddle Green Belt fallacies, maintaining high house-prices and blocking the creation of decent housing for future generations.

back to top


292,287,454

I have been taken to task for negligent editing - a charge which I take very seriously indeed.  I reported this figure to you as the official figure for the US population on 1 January 2004.  But what is the comparable figure, I have been asked, for the enlarged European Union? I did not give it, and I am duly apologetic.

  • On 1 May 2004, the EU population will be 450,000,000. 
    Or thereabouts.


Our hemp
is not your hemp


The Body Shop has answered a question which had, I confess, always puzzled
me.  Does all "hemp" contain psychoactive elements or not?  In their reply to a fund-raising request from the Legalise Cannabis Alliance, this is what the company said -

"Although The Body Shop uses hemp seed oil in several products, it is not
the cannabis you refer to. We use an industrial variety of hemp, cannabis sativa - which contains no psychoactive qualities.

The ingredient which has  psychoactive qualities is called
delta-9 tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) - this is present in only certain varieties of hemp.

Our hemp does not contain delta-9 tetrahydrocannabinol.

We hope to revive the use of hemp in the cosmetics industry because hemp seed oil contains some of the highest known levels of essential fatty acids and therefore is brilliant for moisturising the skin.  We have to list "hemp seed oil" in Latin on our product ingredient listings - hence the words "cannabis sativa".

  • So now you know.

Left Activists' Corner

I have three moderately-left political projects to engage your interest, in 2004 - nothing too revolutionary, you understand...

(a) Company Reform Coalition targeting a major Easter pow-wow in London;

(b) Public Advocates - the birth of a new profession, group also to hold its first London meeting in March;

(c) Labour Links, seeking to unlock the resources of the Labour Party - and I seek the opportunity to speak to Party groups about Party reform

  • Let me know what you think    

back to top


I enjoy dipping into informed US West Coast chat, always up to the minute, which can be found at www.metafilter.com.

 


Recent topics

"Equality?"  An electoral non-starter >>>

My Mum was an Asylum Seeker >>>

Individualism is here to stay >>>

Are you monovascellarist? >>>

Will political parties survive? >>>

Greenleaf Books, and Abdroids >>>

Territorial State v Membership State >>>

My Sikh ideal >>>

Negotiating migration management >>>

Green Belt "politics" >>>

The Strange Howard Credo >>>

Extending the Welfare State >>>

This is my religion >>>

And read my Big Theory itself, at Multiple Differential Uncertainty...

Or try my snappier and more practical analysis of the Corporations and the Left Coming to Terms

back to top


0154  Make sure you have not missed
the previous edition  Check it out   
And the one before that?   
Other recent topics highlighted here

Week 4  Sunday
25 January 2004

 

 

 

 

 

   

 

 
 

 
Created by GMID Design & Communication

COPYRIGHT NOTICE
The originating content of this website is my own work, and subject to my copyright. But on one condition only, I hereby give my consent to its unrestricted reproduction for any purpose: the condition is that its source is subject to proper acknowledgment, giving my name, my assertion of copyright, and the name of this website as its source, namely: www.warrenevans.net
- is that a deal?  Roger WE