|
|
You are in the
company of
Roger Warren Evans |
|
| Part of www.LivePolitics.net < Back to Home Page |
|
Living Diary Index
|
item0075B 1052, 1053 1052 13 December 2004 Eastern
I have just experienced acupuncture treatment, for the first time. Having this week entered my 70th year, my need is to reduce my weight, to match the declining strengths of an ageing frame, in particular to relieve growing shortness of breath. My wife Elizabeth has benefited decisively from acupuncture and its related philosophies. I am attracted by the image of bodily energy flows, although I confess the "evidence" is pretty flimsy. "Western" medicine remains cautious: see the 1997 Declaration by the US medical establishment. But the broad philosophical context of Chinese medicine is attractive, and I am persuaded to experiment.
Roger, Happy birthday! Acupuncture - why not? The curious thing is - it works. The difficulty for Western medicine is to answer the question: Why does it work? I think it works because it is an art practised for well over a thousand years by trial and error. The system is pragmatic. Practitioners have retained a cause and effect link if perceived to have an affect on the subject. The explanation for all this is very metaphoric/figurative, in contrast to the discourse of Western medicine. However, a considerable amount of what passes as “scientific” medical explanation has its own metaphors and rhetorical tropes (more on that another time).
As you
know, acupuncturists adopt a holistic approach to their art — beware for
some unusual questions! - It knocks spots off psychoanalysis. One of the
techniques I do remember is the massaging of the area between thumb and
index finger to relief headaches. If somebody now says it doesn't, that
will make for an interesting philosophical discussion as to what's
happening. I'll have to put it down to distraction therapy. Ed: The lines are still open, on this subject. Can you throw any further light on acupuncture, and its practical effects? If you can Drop me a line
1053 --------- 2004 Moh the Newcastle E What do you think? Drop me a line
|
|
|
| Created by GMID Design & Communication COPYRIGHT
NOTICE
|